The ATO challenged your valuation? Get one that holds.
Independent valuations and second opinions to support an objection or review when the ATO disputes a market value. Senior-reviewed and built to be defended.
If the ATO has challenged a valuation — through a review, an amended assessment or an objection — an independent, well-evidenced valuation is your strongest response. Prismi prepares fresh valuations and second-opinion reviews built specifically to be defended, signed by a senior reviewer.
What usually went wrong
Most disputed valuations share the same weakness: only one method was used, the evidence was not documented, or the report was not independent. Often the ATO is not saying your number is wrong — it is saying the number is not supported. A properly built valuation fixes the support, not just the figure.
How we help
- ·A fresh, independent valuation at the relevant date
- ·A review of the existing valuation — what stands, what does not
- ·Clear documentation of methods, evidence and reasoning
- ·A position your adviser can attach to an objection or response
- ·A senior-reviewer signature and independence statement
Move quickly
Objections and amended assessments run to deadlines. The sooner we have the documents, the sooner you have a report to respond with. We confirm the fixed fee and timing up front, and prioritise matters already under review.
Working with your adviser
We work alongside your accountant or tax lawyer, who manages the objection itself. Prismi provides the independent valuation evidence — we are not a registered tax agent and do not give tax or legal advice.
Common questions.
Can you review a valuation someone else prepared?+
Yes. We can review an existing valuation and tell you honestly where it is strong and where it is exposed, then either support it or prepare a fresh independent report — whichever the evidence justifies.
Will a new valuation guarantee the ATO backs down?+
No one can guarantee an outcome. What we can do is give you the most supportable, properly evidenced position available — which is what an objection needs to succeed on the merits.
Ready to discuss your engagement?
Fifteen-minute discovery call. We confirm the tier, fee and timing before you commit.
Talk to a valuer